The best topwater lures for bluefish are the the ones that make the most commotion and withstand aggressive attacks by monster gorilla blues. Pencil poppers have long been regarded as the best bluefish lure design available on the market. The simple weighted torpedo-like design helps to cast the pencil poppers a great distance to where the fish are biting, even when the wind is blowing. They are durable and available in most colors.
We have picked out our 4 favorite pencil poppers available for purchase from Amazon:
Check out the screenshots from the above video, proving that pencil poppers are the best lures for bluefish on the market today: